Measurement Methodology
Overview
MAPS™ measures M&A capability one pillar at a time and then combines the results into a single readiness picture. The goal is a score you can act on, not a grade to display. A number is only useful if the team can say which practices sit behind it and what would move it.
This page explains how the MAPS Readiness Assessment turns answers into scores, how those scores map to maturity levels, and how the longer-form scoring described in Performance Standards and The 8 Core Pillars relates to it. Read it before you compare two assessment runs, or before you decide which pillar to work on first.
Two Instruments, One Language
MAPS uses two measurement instruments. They share the eight pillars but differ in depth.
The Readiness Assessment is the quick instrument. It asks one question per pillar, eight questions in total, and takes about 5 minutes. Each question has four answer options that describe progressively more mature practice. It is a self-assessment: the person answering describes how the organization works today. It produces a total, a percentage and a maturity level.
The performance-standards review is the deeper instrument. It scores each pillar on a 0-100 scale against process, performance, resource and integration criteria, supported by evidence. It is a way of structuring an internal review or a facilitated engagement. It does not replace the quick assessment, and the quick assessment does not claim to replicate it.
Use the quick assessment to find where to look. Use the standards review to decide what to change.
How the Readiness Assessment Scores
Answer values
Every question offers four options worth 0, 1, 2 or 3 points:
- 3: a documented, governed or validated practice
- 2: a practice that exists and is reviewed, but is less formal
- 1: a partial or informal practice
- 0: no systematic practice
Question 6, Operational Performance & Execution, has a fifth, higher option worth 4 points, for value tracking that is comprehensive and continuous. The maximum possible total is therefore 25 points: seven questions at 3 points plus one at 4. The maximum is calculated from the question data rather than assumed, so it stays correct if an option's value changes.
From points to a percentage
The total is divided by the maximum and rounded to a whole percentage, capped at 100. A run that answers every question with its top option scores 100%. A run that answers every question with its bottom option scores 0%.
Because there is one question per pillar, each pillar contributes roughly an eighth of the result. Question 6 carries a little more weight than the others because of its extra point. Treat the pillar answers as signals. A single question cannot tell you everything about a pillar, and a high total can hide one weak pillar.
Maturity levels
The percentage maps to one of five levels:
| Score | Level | | ------ | ------------------------- | | 85-100 | M&A Excellence Leader | | 70-84 | M&A Advanced Enterprise | | 55-69 | M&A Growing Enterprise | | 40-54 | M&A Emerging Enterprise | | 0-39 | M&A Developing Enterprise |
The levels are bands, not certifications. They describe how formal and repeatable your M&A practice looks from your own answers. They are not an external credential. Each level comes with recommended next steps, and the results page turns those into an ordered improvement plan with suggested timeframes that get longer as maturity rises.
How the Performance Standards Score
The deeper review scores each pillar from 0 to 100 and groups results into bands:
- 90-100: Best in Class
- 80-89: Exceeds Standard
- 70-79: Meets Standard
- 60-69: Approaching Standard
- 0-59: Below Standard
The weighted criteria are process maturity, performance results, resource capability and integration and coordination. Process maturity looks at documentation, training and quality control. Performance results look at history, benchmarks and trend. Resource capability looks at people, tools and funding. Integration looks at how well the pillar works with the others.
Evidence supports each score. The evidence types are process evidence (procedures and training materials), performance evidence (metrics and outcomes), competency evidence (skills and experience records) and application evidence (case studies and project portfolios). A score without evidence should be treated as an estimate.
Reading Your Results
Start with the spread, not the total
Two organizations can both score 62% and need opposite work. One answered 2 on every pillar. The other answered 3 on five pillars and 0 on three. The first needs steady, broad formalization. The second has a concentrated gap, probably in a pillar that was never owned by anyone. Always look at the per-pillar answers before you read the level.
Look at the foundation pillars first
Pillars 1-3 (Strategic Alignment, Financial Discipline, and Governance and Risk) underpin the rest. A 0 or 1 in any of them usually limits what the execution pillars can achieve. If the foundation is weak, fix it before you invest in later pillars.
Compare like with like
Only compare runs that used the same question set. Compare your own results over time instead of comparing against outside organizations. The assessment does not include industry-peer benchmarks, so any comparison with other firms needs data from a separate source, and you should say where it came from.
Re-assess on a schedule
Run the assessment again after each meaningful change, and at least once a year. A rise in score means practices changed. It does not mean deals went better. Pair the score with your own outcome measures, such as whether integration milestones were met or whether the synergy case held, and keep those records alongside the score.
Data Collection Methods
Good measurement depends on how the answers are gathered. These methods work well with MAPS, from lightest to heaviest:
- Individual self-assessment. One senior person answers the eight questions. Fast, but reflects one view.
- Group self-assessment. Several functional leads answer independently, then compare. Disagreement between respondents is itself a finding.
- Document review. Check that the practices people describe exist on paper: playbooks, committee charters, templates, post-deal reviews.
- Stakeholder interviews. Ask the people who ran recent deals what actually happened, not what the policy says.
- Deal retrospectives. Compare plan to outcome on completed transactions and trace gaps back to a pillar.
If the answers matter for a real decision, use at least two of these and record which ones you used.
Limits of the Method
- The quick assessment is self-reported and has not been independently validated. Do not present its result as an audit.
- Eight questions give a coarse view. Use them to prioritize, not to prove.
- Scores say nothing about the quality of any individual deal.
- Levels depend on the question set in use. If the questions or point values change, earlier scores are not directly comparable.
Next Steps
Take the assessment to get your baseline, then use the Implementation Roadmap and Best Practices to act on it. For help reading your results, contact us.